by Daniel Hathaway
Before concert halls became ubiquitous, piano recitals were usually intimate affairs staged in domestic music rooms or salons. Caroline Oltmanns recreated that kind of ambiance during her recital on Sunday afternoon, February 23 at Valley Lutheran Church in Chagrin Falls when she played the annual midwinter piano concert on the Chagrin Valley Chamber Music series.
The room is not large, though the ceiling is lofty. The audience was good-sized for a February Sunday, but not numerous enough to need to be addressed as though it were a public meeting. And the piano, somewhere between a baby grand and a six-footer, was the sort of instrument you might encounter in someone’s living room.
Oltmanns took profit of all of those circumstances to spend an engaging hour communicating directly to her listeners, both through her flawless and eloquent playing and through her running commentary. Her remarks were pithy, apt and informative, and served to put her on an equal footing with the audience even though it was clearly her role to be the professor in the room.
The pianist began and ended her program with Chopin: the Fantasie Impromtu in c-sharp, op. 66 and the Scherzo in c-sharp, op. 39, explaining that both pieces featured a middle section in D-flat but of quite different character. She played op. 66 with graceful elegance.
Oltmanns went on to caution the audience that Beethoven’s “Waldstein” Sonata, op. 53 would require the most concentration on their part of any piece on the program, but went on to make their job easier with a performance remarkable for its clarity of concept and architectural coherence. The undersized piano responded bravely but was probably happy that the performer didn’t ask more of it than it had to offer.
Turning next to modern music, Oltmanns spoke fondly of George Crumb’s Morning Music from Markrokosmos II, noting that if you didn’t like it, it would only last two minutes. Demonstrating one way of “preparing” a piano, she tucked a sheet of paper among the strings, then gave an absorbing account of a little piece that even the most conservative listener could feel friendly toward.
After sharing a bit of biographical information about the ever-colorful Eric Satie, including his need to make some “money on the side” to support his absinthe habit, Caroline Oltmanns treated her listeners to an amusing journey through Je te veux, one such pot-boiler (or pour boirer?) that might have penetrated the smoky air at Le Chat Noir.
Oltmann’s last comments prefaced the Chopin scherzo and chronicled his attempted move to Mallorca to improve his health. Facing hostility from the natives, he, George Sand and her two children ended up exiled and pianoless in a convent where he wrote op. 39 with its chorale-like middle section. “It’s almost a religious experience,” she noted. And it was.
In response to an immediate standing ovation, Oltmanns offered a quasi-jazz encore, an exercise by Friedrich Gulda, who once taught Martha Argerich. That brought a near-perfectly proportioned Sunday afternoon piano recital to a fine conclusion.
Published on ClevelandClassical.com February 25, 2014
Click here for a printable version of this article.